MSFTextrememakeover

Thursday, November 30, 2006

Buy the rumor, sell the news?

That's what it looked like today, following the formal business availability of Vista/Office/Exchange and Ballmer ringing the opening bell at the NASDAQ market:

Of course, it might have been that lesser-known adage "If Ballmer's talking in public, sell!". That one has a near-perfect track record of success. See his webcast here btw, if interested (I didn't bother).

Getting back to the chart, check out that EOD sell volume. Not exactly the kind of reception you'd like to have on such a day. Yes, there has been quite a run up recently. However, that's also true of competitors GOOG and AAPL, yet both managed to perform better on the day despite any equivalent news. At least volume wasn't that high - that's something to be thankful for. But the long-worried about $30 ceiling is starting to look pretty formidable here, and it's unclear what positive news MSFT has left that isn't already in the market.

As always, the timing of Gates' regular dumping didn't help. Given that the only quarter he didn't sell in recent history was - conveniently - the one right before the tender and increased buyback announcement that sparked the recent run up, it would have been nice if he could have passed on another quarter to give the stock a chance at finally breaking through $30. But alas, no such luck - and maybe it wouldn't have helped anyway.

I also see that short interest has been on a tear recently. The author attributes it to disappointment over ZUNE, but my take is that it's simply traders making a bet that the stock is now effectively out of "good news" gas (some of it five years in the making) and yet, even with that, hasn't managed to take out the 4 year old trading range top convincingly. As such, the odds of it doing so are falling, while the odds of a trip back down are increasing. It's the old "the trend is your friend" phenomenon.

So, is the company out of good news gas? Are there some positive developments still unknown by the street? Have they completed all their buybacks or is there still some significant amount to do? Is this just the pause that refreshes? Are some of the executives going to finally put their wallet behind their "confidence and optimism" and actually buy some shares? Okay, forget that particular pipe dream. Or are the short-interest traders right and this was just another trip to the top on the MSFT yo-yo before heading back down? I guess we'll find out...

Update: Even this fairly significant news during the session didn't help:

Update #2: Looks like we're getting our answer, as the stock has clearly broken the previous uptrend and disconnected from the market - once again.

3 Comments:

  • Wow, I didn't believe you until I ran the numbers myself. Using dates from speeches listed here: http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/exec/steve/default.mspx and yahoo's historical charting like so: http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=MSFT&a=11&b=1&c=2006&d=11&e=1&f=2006&g=d, I get the following: (I apologize in advance for excel-text conversion)


    Steve Ballmer Keynote: Microsoft Office "12" Project and Visio Conference 19-Jan 26.87 27.24 26.85 27.02 60,367,600 26.63 -0.24 0.15
    3GSM World Congress 14-Feb 26.41 26.68 26.35 26.65 58,432,900 26.27 -0.14 0.24
    The People-Ready Business 16-Mar 27.34 27.48 27.22 27.27 73,793,696 26.97 -0.37 -0.07
    Western Washington University Business Forum 18-Apr 26.94 27.5 26.82 27.22 56,272,700 26.92 -0.02 0.28
    World Congress on IT 3-May 23.99 24.02 23.15 23.17 211,527,104 22.92 -1.07 -0.82
    MSN Strategic Account Summit 4-May 23.35 23.67 23.14 23.44 171,257,408 23.18 -0.17 0.09
    Commonwealth Club/Churchill Club 11-May 23.71 23.79 23.15 23.22 92,916,704 22.97 -0.74 -0.49
    Steve Ballmer: Sanford C. Bernstein & Co. Strategic Decisions Conference 31-May 23.26 23.35 22.65 22.65 120,202,000 22.49 -0.77 -0.61
    New Era of Technical Leadership for Microsoft - Press Conference 15-Jun 22.01 22.13 21.8 22.07 121,577,296 21.91 -0.1 0.06
    Worldwide Partner Conference 2006 11-Jul 23.37 23.37 22.74 23.1 88,676,304 22.94 -0.43 -0.27
    Financial Analyst Meeting 2006 27-Jul 24.58 24.6 23.77 23.87 85,386,800 23.7 -0.88 -0.71
    Gartner Symposium/IT Expo 2006 10-Oct 27.69 27.75 27.44 27.69 34,598,500 27.6 -0.09 0
    American Chamber of Commerce in Egypt 19-Oct 28.35 28.45 28.12 28.29 44,730,800 28.19 -0.16 -0.06
    Microsoft and Novell Collaboration Announcement 2-Nov 28.71 28.86 28.58 28.77 58,674,400 28.67 -0.04 0.06
    Japan Partner Conference 6-Nov 28.77 29.05 28.76 28.84 60,446,200 28.74 -0.03 0.07
    A New Day for Business Launch Event 30-Nov 29.42 29.57 29.33 29.36 53,297,400 29.36 -0.06 -0.06

    Giving an average of -5.31, adjusted price for those days.

    Taking a volume-based approach, and going by whichever day had highest volume, shows this:


    Steve Ballmer Keynote: Microsoft Office "12" Project and Visio Conference 20-Jan 27.01 27.01 26.26 26.41 79,165,904 26.03 -0.98 -0.6
    3GSM World Congress 15-Feb 26.6 26.93 26.5 26.88 62,808,900 26.59 -0.01 0.28
    The People-Ready Business 17-Mar 27.35 27.66 27.27 27.5 120,615,000 27.2 -0.15 0.15
    Western Washington University Business Forum 18-Apr 26.94 27.5 26.82 27.22 56,272,700 26.92 -0.02 0.28
    World Congress on IT 3-May 23.99 24.02 23.15 23.17 211,527,104 22.92 -1.07 -0.82
    MSN Strategic Account Summit 4-May 23.35 23.67 23.14 23.44 171,257,408 23.18 -0.17 0.09
    Commonwealth Club/Churchill Club 11-May 23.71 23.79 23.15 23.22 92,916,704 22.97 -0.74 -0.49
    Steve Ballmer: Sanford C. Bernstein & Co. Strategic Decisions Conference 31-May 23.26 23.35 22.65 22.65 120,202,000 22.49 -0.77 -0.61
    New Era of Technical Leadership for Microsoft - Press Conference 16-Jun 21.97 22.28 21.79 22.1 147,506,496 21.94 -0.03 0.13
    Worldwide Partner Conference 2006 11-Jul 23.37 23.37 22.74 23.1 88,676,304 22.94 -0.43 -0.27
    Financial Analyst Meeting 2006 27-Jul 24.58 24.6 23.77 23.87 85,386,800 23.7 -0.88 -0.71
    Gartner Symposium/IT Expo 2006 11-Oct 27.46 27.67 27.42 27.54 37,219,600 27.45 -0.01 0.08
    American Chamber of Commerce in Egypt 20-Oct 28.48 28.49 28.17 28.43 48,887,800 28.33 -0.15 -0.05
    Microsoft and Novell Collaboration Announcement 2-Nov 28.71 28.86 28.58 28.77 58,674,400 28.67 -0.04 0.06
    Japan Partner Conference 6-Nov 28.77 29.05 28.76 28.84 60,446,200 28.74 -0.03 0.07
    A New Day for Business Launch Event 1-Dec 29.23 29.3 28.9 29.12 72,257,000 29.12 -0.11 -0.11

    Adjusted sum, that's -5.59, or non-adjusted, -2.52, lost on the days SteveB gives a speech. I wish I had the statistics to show how likely that was, but I'll leave that as an exercise for the reader. Good tip!

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 11:00 PM  

  • Buy the silence, sell the Ballmer. Good advice.

    Problem is, Ballmer talks more than a caffinated Parrot with Turret's Syndrome. Louder too.

    Seriously though, I think he's the kind of guy who is just an accelerator for whatever trend is already going on. When the company was making money hand over fist, his schtick was funny and made people say "wow, look at all that passion. I wish every CEO was like that." When the company is struggling, he just looks like a clown and makes people ask "Wow, is he the best they can do?"

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:11 PM  

  • So how about that google and their move to enable the auctioning of options? While we wait and watch in pain our under water options expire, google is finding another way to retain and keep there employees happy. (sigh)

    thoughts?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:15 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home